Teams 
| Player | Year |
|---|---|
| Most Valuable Player | |
| Joey Votto | 2010 |
| Barry Larkin | 1995 |
| George Foster | 1977 |
| Joe Morgan | 1976 |
| Joe Morgan | 1975 |
| Pete Rose | 1973 |
| Johnny Bench | 1972 |
| Johnny Bench | 1970 |
| Frank Robinson | 1961 |
| Frank McCormick | 1940 |
| Bucky Walters | 1939 |
| Ernie Lombardi | 1938 |
| Rookie of the Year | |
| Scott Williamson | 1999 |
| Chris Sabo | 1988 |
| Pat Zachry | 1976 |
| Johnny Bench | 1968 |
| Tommy Helms | 1966 |
| Pete Rose | 1963 |
| Frank Robinson | 1956 |
| Manager of the Year | |
| Jack McKeon | 1999 |
| NLCS Most Valuable Player | |
| Rob Dibble | 1990 |
| Randy Myers | 1990 |
| World Series Most Valuable Player | |
| Jose Rijo | 1990 |
| Johnny Bench | 1976 |
| Pete Rose | 1975 |
| All-Star Game Most Valuable Player | |
| Dave Concepcion | 1982 |
| Ken Griffey Sr. | 1980 |
| George Foster | 1976 |
| Joe Morgan | 1972 |
| Tony Perez | 1967 |
| Gold Gloves | |
| Joey Votto (1B), Brandon Phillips (2B) | 2011 |
| Bronson Arroyo (P), Brandon Phillips (2B), Scott Rolen (3B) | 2010 |
| Brandon Phillips (2B) | 2008 |
| Pokey Reese (2B) | 2000 |
| Pokey Reese (2B) | 1999 |
| Bret Boone (2B) | 1998 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1996 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1995 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1994 |
| Eric Davis (OF) | 1989 |
| Eric Davis (OF) | 1988 |
| Eric Davis (OF) | 1987 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1979 |
| Cesar Geronimo (OF) | 1977 |
| Joe Morgan (2B) | 1977 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1977 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1977 |
| Cesar Geronimo (OF) | 1976 |
| Joe Morgan (2B) | 1976 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1976 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1976 |
| Cesar Geronimo (OF) | 1975 |
| Joe Morgan (2B) | 1975 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1975 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1975 |
| Cesar Geronimo (OF) | 1974 |
| Joe Morgan (2B) | 1974 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1974 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1974 |
| Joe Morgan (2B) | 1973 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1973 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1972 |
| Tommy Helms (2B) | 1971 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1971 |
| Tommy Helms (2B) | 1970 |
| Pete Rose (OF) | 1970 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1970 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1969 |
| Pete Rose (OF) | 1969 |
| Johnny Bench (C) | 1968 |
| Leo Cardenas (SS) | 1965 |
| Johnny Edwards (C) | 1964 |
| Johnny Edwards (C) | 1963 |
| Vada Pinson (OF) | 1961 |
| Roy McMillan (SS) | 1959 |
| Harvey Haddix (P) | 1958 |
| Roy McMillan (SS) | 1958 |
| Frank Robinson (LF) | 1958 |
| Roy McMillan (SS) | 1957 |
| Silver Slugger | |
| Brandon Phillips (2B) | 2011 |
| Felipe Lopez (SS) | 2005 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1999 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1998 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1996 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1995 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1992 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1991 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1990 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1989 |
| Eric Davis (OF) | 1989 |
| Barry Larkin (SS) | 1988 |
| Eric Davis (OF) | 1987 |
| Dave Parker (OF) | 1986 |
| Dave Parker (OF) | 1985 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1982 |
| Dave Concepcion (SS) | 1981 |
| George Foster (OF) | 1981 |
| Relief Man | |
| Jeff Shaw | 1997 |
| Jeff Brantley | 1996 |
| John Franco | 1988 |
| Rawly Eastwick | 1976 |
| Roberto Clemente Award | |
| Barry Larkin | 1993 |
| Pete Rose | 1976 |
| The Sporting News Player of the Year | |
| Joe Morgan | 1976 |
| Joe Morgan | 1975 |
| Johnny Bench | 1970 |
| Johnny Vander Meer | 1938 |
